As a little kid I would rather play "make believe" than tag or hide-and-seek, leading to me often being alone or with a few friends at recess. At family social gatherings I preferred sitting with the adults over conversation and tomfoolery with my siblings and cousins. The latter behavior has lead to people, including myself, often referring to me as an "old soul."
High school and college were awkward times. During those retched eight years I constantly felt inadequate and tried desperately to fit in with different niches. The thing about that is that each little niche, each friend I made, were things and people I truly liked. They were just different aspects of myself that did not seem to blend together nicely in any one thing or person/group.
Now an adult myself, I am finding that things are not much better. I thought they would be. I thought I would be further along in my self-development than I am; have my little quirks and people to indulge in them with.
I'm not. I don't.
Let's face it: people are complex creatures. We like to smush ourselves into one personality type or social grouping, and I don't think that approach is sufficient for many of us.
In my case it tends to hurt me, to drive me away from people, places, and opportunities. Trying to fit in and trying to let people in works for a little while, but sooner or later the biting urge to push it away is back again. I push people back, take a step back because they aren't...what? Aren't worthy enough? Aren't just exactly what I need? I'm not sure. I just know I can't let them get that close. If I do, they'll learn things about me, intimate details of my psyche, and that's not okay.
It's wearing on me.
Loner tends to have negative connotations, but truly I like to be alone. Being by myself, left to my own devices, thoughts, and whimsies. There is comfort in the solitude. Comfort in the knowledge that I don't need to worry about someone else and what they're thinking about me. If they're thinking about me at all.
No, I crave crawling back into silence, away from the false smiles and half-posed questions of the day-to-day. Back to the only person who truly understands me and truly cares: me.
It all boils down to trust in my case. On top of my introvert-ism I also have trust issues—I don't trust anyone outright. Rather than giving people the benefit of the doubt, they need to prove themselves trustworthy to me. Most people make it to the trust-you-to-a-point place on the scale, meaning I trust them in many ways with many things, but not enough to feel I can divulge my deepest feelings to them. I may open up a little about things/feelings going on, but most of the time I simply say, "Oh, I'm fine."
It's frustrating, and I'm not sure how to break through it. I'm naturally protective, especially of myself, and slightly suspicious, especially of those who try to get close to me. Why would they? They don't know me.
I'm a mess. I guess I'm okay with that, but it doesn't help the loneliness.
Should I let my guard down a little? Throw out some bait and see who takes a nibble? Perhaps.
Or perhaps one of these days I will find someone, or even a group of people, with whom I am able to connect with. People who I have things in common with and can just be myself—without having to resort to uncomfortableness to get there.
Besides, keeping things close to the vest automatically makes me "mysterious," and I do like the idea of that.
—E